Writing Boots

On communication, professional and otherwise.

Kids aren’t sponges; grownups are stones

10.27.2009 by David Murray // 15 Comments

Last night I went to bed with the TV on. I thought I'd multitask, listening to a PBS documentary about Herbert Hoover and falling asleep at the same time. I was surprised to learn—and eager to tell people at cocktail parties from now on—that Hoover, a self-made orphan, rose to prominence because he actually invented a system for large-scale relief, feeding 9 million starving Belgians throughout World War I!

Oh, how I would have amazed my friends and confused my enemies by talking about how Hoover went down in history as an uncaring laissez-faire Republican who left Americans to starve during the Depression.

I would have, if I hadn't dozed off at about the 14-minute mark.

I tell another anecdote about adult learning and television when I give speeches on speechwriting. It illustrates why it's so important to focus speeches not on three ideas or even two, but rather one, and one alone. (Or, as James Carville once described his job as a communication aide: to "empty full vessels.")

One evening a few years ago I sat down with a glass of wine and started clicking through the channels. I lighted like a butterfly on the beginning of a PBS special on dogs. The documentary would specifically address, the sonorous narrator explained, why dogs, all descended from the wolf, now come in so many shapes and sizes.

Well that's a damned interesting question, I thought to myself, and worthy of the next hour of my life.

Then the narrator explained that there are two theories as to how a relatively homogeneous population of wolves begat the modern canine-ucopia.

Oh, damn, I thought. I know my mind, and I know I'm not going to remember two theories. I'm only going to remember one theory.

But I hunkered down anyway, and listened intently as the narrator explained the first theory. It guesses that when people started domesticating wolves, they picked only the gentlest ones, thereby causing an artificial selection process which mated gentle wolves with gentle wolves and created mutations that eventually led to the chihuahua and other biological abominations that scurry between our feet and bark at nothing and shake, shiver and shit on little pads in the corner. (Don't get me started.)

And what was the other theory? I ask the audience rhetorically.

I don't remember the other effing theory! I bellow in freshly felt frustration.

The lesson for communicators being: It's hard to get stuff into grownups heads. Grownups always go around calling kids "sponges." It's not that kids are sponges. It's just that kids can actually learn stuff. Why? Brain theories aside, they have other advantages: They're not too self-conscious to fully listen, they're not immediately packaging every lesson for some practical use, they're not terrified somebody's going to quiz them and humiliate them for not remembering, and they don't drink wine.

But why kids learn and grownups don't isn't the point.

The point is: If you're gonna get an idea into a grownup's head, you've got to hit hard, straight, often and from different angles.

And since getting ideas in grownups' heads is what we do for a living, it seems we ought to keep this squarely in mind.

Now, what was I saying about Herbert Hoover? Oh yes …..

Categories // Uncategorized Tags // adult learning, communication, kids learn, PBS, speeches, sponges, stupid little jerky dogs

Are you touching others, or just touching yourself?

10.22.2009 by David Murray // Leave a Comment

Writing Boots’ Hong Kong correspondent, speechwriter Lorne Christensen, alerts us to this speech, given in support of a gay marriage law in Maine, last spring. He calls it “a humble and powerful speech from the heart,” and adds that its genuineness would appeal to people on either side of the gay marriage debate.

As far as I’m concerned, that’s the test all communication has to pass—does it affect (even subtly, even silently) the sworn enemies of the idea it espouses? Or does it only excite those who agreed in the first place?

Categories // Uncategorized Tags // communication, gay marriage, Maine, speech, WWII Veteran

Michael Moore considers retirement because his documentaries don’t effect behavior change

09.15.2009 by David Murray // 17 Comments

I've written more than a million words, and only one article I've ever written had a demonstrable on anything. Did it comfort the afflicted? Did it afflict the comfortable? No, it helped pressure the city of Chicago to improve the Park District golf courses.

Big fucking whoop, right? Well, what's the biggest measurable change your writing has effected?

Now here comes documentary-maker Michael Moore, quoted on the Huffington Post saying his latest documentary, Capitalism: A Love Story, might be his last.

Why? Because people aren't doing what he's telling them to do:

I've done this for 20 years. I started out by warning people about
General Motors, and my whole career has been trying to say the emperor
has no clothes here, and we better do something about it. I've been having to sort of knock my head against the wall here for 20
years saying these things.

Two years ago, I tried to get the health-care debate going, and it did
eventually, and now where are we? We may not even have it. What am I
supposed to do at a certain point?

You're supposed to … keep making documentaries, fool! What else are you going to do fatass, join the NBA? This is what you do. It's the only thing anybody will pay you to do.

And you know as well as I do—just like any professional communicator who promises his or her work will lead to demonstrable results—that communication is faith: The belief that what you're dishing out is providing comfort to someone who needs it, is upsetting someone who has it coming, and is doing some good, somehow, somewhere, some way.

And anybody who demands more control than that from mass communications either has a dictator complex or is trying to promote a movie.

Categories // Uncategorized Tags // behavior change, Capitalism: A Love Story, communication, Huffington Post, Michael Moore

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • …
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7

Now Available

An Effort to Understand

Order Now

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE BLOG UPDATES

About

David Murray writes on communication issues.
Read More

 

Categories

  • Baby Boots
  • Communication Philosophy
  • Efforts to Understand
  • Happy Men, and Other Eccentrics
  • Human Politicians
  • Mister Boring
  • Murray Cycle Diaries
  • Old Boots
  • Rambling, At Home and Abroad
  • Sports Stories
  • The Quotable Murr
  • Typewriter Truths
  • Uncategorized
  • Weird Scenes Inside the Archives

Archives

Copyright © 2025 · Log in

  • Preorder An Effort to Understand
  • Sign Up for Blog Updates
  • About David Murray