Writing Boots

On communication, professional and otherwise.

The hack’s motto: “Everybody needs an editor”

01.13.2010 by David Murray // 5 Comments

A bracing yarn comes at the end of "Ghost Writers," an essay by Cynthia Ozick, included in the 2009 edition of The Best American Essays (my annual writing seminar).

After spending seven years on a first novel that went unpublished, she spent another seven on Novel Two and sent 800 pages to a publisher:

Back came the manuscript in the mail, with one hundred pages all marked up in red pencil, and a note. The note said, "If you do everything my red pencil suggests, and of course there will be more in this vein, we will accept your novel for publication. But if you decline to follow my red pencil's indispensable advice, then we will decline to publish." Fourteen years gone! Outrun by the cohort of my generation, I lusted for print as Jacob had panted after Rachel. To the editor I wrote: "Seven years I have labored for those words, and yet another seven years; so I say unto you, Nay, not one jot or tittle will I alter or undo." To which the editor replied, "O.K., we'll take it anyway."

Contrary to the huffy mantra, "everybody needs an editor," that we hear from workaday writers like corporate communicators and journalists, a writer who has tried to make something perfect ought to bristle at heavy editing.

Often those edits do turn out to be useful, but the only reason a writer necessarily needs an editor is if he or she hasn't enough talent for the job, hasn't put forth the effort, hasn't spent enough time at it, or is writing to please someone else and not him- or herself.

Which is a lot of us, a lot of the time.

But let's not be self-righteous about it, shall we?

Categories // Uncategorized Tags // "everybody needs an editor", editors and writers, hack

Comments

  1. Kristen says

    January 13, 2010 at 10:06 am

    On the topic of “needing editors” have you seen this, David? I came across it yesterday and though I can’t remember where exactly I saw it [the downside of too many social media channels] it absolutely made me howl. Can you say “Irony”?!
    http://jonslattery.blogspot.com/2009/11/sub-editor-takes-revenge-on-publisher.html

    Reply
  2. David Murray says

    January 13, 2010 at 10:10 am

    Delightful.
    All senior executives, whether they work for newspapers or not, DO need editors.

    Reply
  3. Greg says

    January 15, 2010 at 3:44 pm

    The fact that everybody needs an editor has kept me in beer and guitar strings for 26 years. May this happy condition never change!

    Reply
  4. fire damage in cedar park says

    January 22, 2013 at 11:24 pm

    fire damage in cedar park

    Writing Boots: The hack’s motto: “Everybody needs an editor”

    Reply
  5. fire damage in cedar park says

    January 22, 2013 at 11:24 pm

    fire damage in cedar park

    Writing Boots: The hack’s motto: “Everybody needs an editor”

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Now Available

An Effort to Understand

Order Now

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE BLOG UPDATES

About

David Murray writes on communication issues.
Read More

 

Categories

  • Baby Boots
  • Communication Philosophy
  • Efforts to Understand
  • Happy Men, and Other Eccentrics
  • Human Politicians
  • Mister Boring
  • Murray Cycle Diaries
  • Old Boots
  • Rambling, At Home and Abroad
  • Sports Stories
  • The Quotable Murr
  • Typewriter Truths
  • Uncategorized
  • Weird Scenes Inside the Archives

Archives

Copyright © 2023 ยท Log in

  • Preorder An Effort to Understand
  • Sign Up for Blog Updates
  • About David Murray